Dean Frisbee threatens to resign his post at Cuthbert College when he learns that Superman has been invited to be a guest lecturer, which he believes will destroy the campus's isolation and tranquility. Coincidentally, a lost spaceman from Betelgeuse arrives on campus, and makes Frisbee an offer he can't refuse - in exchange for providing the alien with first-hand knowledge of Earth, he will rid the campus of Superman. Will the plan protect Cuthbert College, or will it backfire on Dean Frisbee?